Showing posts with label mass media. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mass media. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Did you know ... political groups try to frame public health issues FOR you?


I have been researching common advertising themes that are effective among younger populations, and I came upon this Web site today. The Center for Consumer Freedom is an industry-funded site that purports to tell "the truth" about obesity ...

- The government is controlling you by calling out food manufacturers about their shoddy labeling;
- The government is interfering in your basic rights to be an American;
- Obesity is not caused by fatty foods;
- Exercise will cure all obesity;
- Sugary sodas are good for you because they help the performance of elite athletes (seriously, this is their argument. See study here and "unbiased" interpretation here).

I must admit that their ad campaign is incredibly clever, appealing to basic American principles such as freedom of choice, independence, liberty, etc., etc. However, it's important to recognize that this is all a sham, at least from a public health perspective.

The food lobby is using the same arguments that the tobacco companies used in the past few decades: Our product isn't dangerous for you because we say it isn't! Your freedom to eat (smoke) is being infringed upon! NO MORE BIG GOVERNMENT!!! BLAHHH!!!!

Have you ever wondered why they're using these outdated and ridiculous arguments? Maybe it's because many food giants are actually owned by tobacco companies (as you might find in this awesome article about marketing food to children). For example, Philip Morris, under its alias Altria, owns both Nabisco and Kraft foods. Are we surprised that they're using the same detrimental marketing and social influence techniques to make sure their products remain on the market?

I'm all about supporting individuals' right to choose, but I'm also all about them receiving accurate information about what they're putting in their bodies. If I know that my food is chock full of chemicals, and I understand the ramifications of eating that food, then I assume responsibility for my consumption patterns. If, however, I am coerced into believing that the food I eat is NOT HARMFUL, how can I be expected to make reasonable decisions about my diet?

Again, I think Twinkies and Ding Dongs have their place (i.e., occasionally on my plate), but I understand the risk associated with those products. I wonder whether the rest of the nation really "gets" what's going on ... or whether they're being manipulated by the same crappy companies that used to market cigarettes to kids and the urban poor.

Also, let's not forget that industry-sponsored initiatives often prompt the "boomerang" effect, encouraging people to engage in the negative behavior instead of preventing illness. Ex: The tobacco industry's anti-smoking ads actually encouraged more kids to smoke (as we addressed in an an earlier post on this blog). Do you think McDonald's or Coke's fitness initiatives are really going to promote health? Or are they a surreptitious way to promote inactivity?

Looks like a job for The Public Health Models. We'll keep you updated on this topic.

Thursday, June 23, 2011

Graphic cigarette labels ... really?

Take a look at these:


Pretty pictures of new warnings that will be included on cigarette packs per 2009 legislation.

Now, take a look at any of the following:
Ineffectiveness of fear appeals in youth
How to use fear appeals
Fear appeals in traffic safety


When a person believes that he is not vulnerable to a risk, his behaviour will not be affected by information about the serious consequences and the recommendations for effective behaviour.
In other words ... now, stay with me ... fear appeals are largely ineffective, especially among younger populations. In simple terms, this is because young people don't understand how to effectively estimate risk. This is the root of the common "it won't happen to me" phenomenon, and the reason that many teenagers are drawn to risky behavior. Their brains are quite literally unable to process the seriousness of the danger inherent in many behaviors and situations.

Also, we've tried stuff like this before, when the tobacco companies were required to advertise to prevent youngsters from initiating smoking: Evaluation of youth response to tobacco-company sponsored messages.
Not surprisingly, these companies crafted their messages to appeal to adults who needed a warm, fuzzy feeling ... but the teen smoking rate increased. That's right, the public health ads that were supposed to prevent kids from smoking actually prompted more young people to light up. Brilliant!

What makes us think, then, that young people won't just discount these messages, ridiculing them in a defensive response? My prediction is that is exactly what's going to happen. These messages will be, at best (in younger populations), completely ineffective because they're mocked by kids for being entirely too graphic.

Even more importantly, sometimes fear appeals such as these can have an iatrogenic effect; that is, the intervention worsens the problem. Fear appeals provoke a defensive mechanism that prompts target audiences to engage in dangerous behavior simply to prove that they're immune to the behavior's negative health effects. In other words, people might start smoking more as a proverbial "middle finger" to the public health campaign. "See, I can do it, and I won't die!" ... or, they'll rationalize their behavior by pointing to anecdata that supports their behavior. Ex: "My grandpa smoked a pack a day for 80 years, and he lived forever."

Anyway, way to go, FDA, for being completely unoriginal and refusing to acknowledge the massive body of research that indicates the complete worthlessness of fear appeals. This legislation passed because we have a bunch of uneducated, self-righteous politicians who want to make themselves feel better because they're doing something. Well, they did something before, involving the tobacco companies, and they succeeded in making the problem worse instead of lowering smoking rates among our nation's youth.

Only time will tell whether this intervention will follow the same path.

ETA: Does anyone else think this is going to cause an increase in the sales of cigarette cases? I would rather have my smokes in a stylish vintage box instead of one of these horrifying boxes. People really can circumvent any intervention.

UPDATE: Check out this awesome editorial, which proves my point --- Smokers unmoved by graphic ads